Add To Itinerary

The Theater at Carlisle Inn

Carlisle Inn Sugarcreek is happy to present a new entertainment option for visitors to Ohio's Amish Country - a live theater production in the heart of beautiful Amish Country. We've chosen to place our stage in the center of our cozy 190-seat theater. With seating surrounding the stage, you'll feel close to the actors, almost as if you are in the middle of the scene. Seating will be assigned according to best available seat.

Playing in 2014:
The Confession Musical – June 3 to August 16
After another successful theater season, Carlisle Inn again is pleased to present a third run of The Confession Musical. This musical is based upon The Heritage of Lancaster County trilogy of novels written by Beverly Lewis, who USA Today hails as the ‘queen of the genre’ when it comes to Amish love stories. The storyline comes from the books, The Shunning, The Confession, and The Reckoning. At the center is of the musical is Katie Lapp, a young Amish woman who is caught in the middle of secrets and scandal, love lost and love found, and personal heartache and healing.

Half-Stitched, The Musical – August 22 to December 20
From bestselling novelist, Wanda Brunstetter, Half-Stitched features the story of a group of mismatched strangers attending the Amish Quilting Club. But as these beginning quilters learn to transform scraps of material into beauty, their fragmented lives begin to take new shape with the helping hands of each other and the healing hand of God. Join the club of unlikely quilters who show up for Amish widow Emma Yoder's quilting classes.

1357 Old Route 39

Sugarcreek, Ohio 44681

Phone Number(s)

Reservations: 855-344-7547

E-mail Address(es)

Special Hours: Find our schedule of shows at


Purchase Tickets
Calendar of Events



Accepted Forms of Payment

Cash, Discover, Mastercard, Visa



Shared Itineraries

Loading Data...
Next Month Previous Month October 2014
Select a date from above or try our
Event Calendar Search
Free publications read online or order print versions Online Travel Tools
Get Fit Naturally - ODNR

Stay Informed

Keep up-to-date with information from our custom Discover Ohio e-newsletters.

Email Address

Read Online Order Print Versions